We earn a commission from third-party booking links, at no extra cost to you
Mad Hatters Bermuda: Whimsical Dining and Fusion Cuisine in Hamilton
$$, European with Thai and American Fusion
Updated: October 2026
If you walk a few blocks inland from the main harbor in the City of Hamilton, you will find one of the most consistently excellent restaurants in Bermuda. Mad Hatters sits on Richmond Road, completely out of sight from the cruise ships and waterfront crowds.
The concept here is brilliantly contradictory. You get the high-level culinary execution of a fine dining establishment, but you eat your meal while wearing a giant, fuzzy sombrero or a vintage pilot's helmet.
At a Glance
| Feature |
Description |
| Best For |
Couples, foodies, and fun group dinners |
| Price Range |
Moderate to High (Great value set lunch available) |
| Location |
22 Richmond Road, Hamilton (Inland) |
| Vibe |
Quirky, intimate, and highly interactive |
| Reservations |
Mandatory (Phone only) |
Why Mad Hatters is a Hamilton Staple
For years, co-owner Mark Turner and head chef Ben Jewett have run this beloved local spot with a focus on personality and flavor. The restaurant is famous for the massive collection of eccentric hats lining the walls. Diners are heavily encouraged to pull them down and wear them throughout the meal.
Source: Mad Hatters
The real draw, however, is the consistency of the kitchen. While many restaurants rely on a waterfront view to sell tables, Mad Hatters relies entirely on word of mouth and exceptional food.
The open kitchen design means you can hear the sizzle of pans and smell the rich garlic and seafood reductions the moment you walk through the door.
Who This is For / Who Should Skip
This restaurant is perfect for travelers who want a memorable, unpretentious night out. It is ideal for couples looking for a cozy corner, or small groups of friends who enjoy sharing dishes and a few laughs. If you appreciate chefs who experiment with daily market catches, you will love it here.
You should skip Mad Hatters if you demand a sweeping ocean view with your dinner. The restaurant is entirely indoors and tucked away on a city side street. It is also not the place for ultra-formal, whisper-quiet dining; the atmosphere is lively, and the tables are packed closely together.
The Menu: European Classics Meet Thai-American Fusion
Many visitors search online for a static Mad Hatters menu, but you will not find a permanent one. The kitchen operates on a foundation of European classics fused with Thai and North American influences, but the magic happens on their daily specials board.
Chef Ben Jewett changes the offerings constantly based on what fresh seafood and local produce are available that morning.
Source: Mad Hatters
You can usually expect staples like a perfectly cooked filet mignon or a rich seafood pasta, but the Thai-spiced curries and fresh wahoo dishes are where the kitchen truly shines.
If you want to experience their food on a budget, their two-course set lunch menu for around $30-$40 is one of the best dining deals in Hamilton.
They are also highly accommodating for dietary restrictions, making this a great addition to your
Gluten Free and Vegan Dining in Bermuda itinerary.
Source: Mad Hatters
What Surprises Visitors the Most
The sheer size of the restaurant catches most first-timers off guard. The interior only holds about eight tables, creating a dinner party atmosphere rather than a standard restaurant vibe. The space is tight, and you will likely end up chatting with the tables next to you.
The open kitchen is another major surprise. It is right in the dining room, meaning you can watch the chefs work the line. Do not be surprised if the chef steps out to explain a dish or joke with your table.
Pro-Tip: The hats are washed regularly, but if you are a germaphobe, you might want to skip putting one on your head. Just grab one for a quick photo instead.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
The biggest mistake travelers make is trying to book a table via email. Mad Hatters is old-school and only accepts reservations over the phone. If you send an email, it will likely go unread, and you will show up to find no table waiting for you.
Another common error is ignoring the waiter when they recite the daily specials. The printed menu is good, but the blackboard specials are almost always the best things in the house.
Finally, do not try to walk in without a reservation on a Friday or Saturday night. With only eight tables, they book up weeks in advance.
Practical Details and Reservations
Finding the restaurant requires a short walk from the main shopping district. Head up Bermudiana Road from the western end of Front Street, and continue straight as it merges into Richmond Road. Look for the modest signage; the entrance can be easy to miss if you are walking fast.
Location: 22 Richmond Road, City of Hamilton.
Reservations: Call +1 441-297-6231 to book.
Hours: Open for lunch and dinner. They are strictly closed on Sundays and Mondays.
Dress Code: Smart casual. You do not need a jacket, but avoid beachwear or flip-flops.
Payment: Credit cards are accepted, but having cash for a tip is always appreciated by the staff.
Road Map
Alternatives Nearby
If Mad Hatters is fully booked, you still have great options in the area. For a highly casual pint and pub food, the
Robin Hood Pub is located directly across the street. It is a fantastic spot to grab a drink while you wait for your table, too.
If you decide you really want a water view, grab a taxi to the
Harbourfront Restaurant on 40 Crow Lane. For an upscale, quiet seafood experience in the city center, check out
Barracuda Grill.
About the Author
By Raj Bhattacharya
Raj has been writing about Bermuda since 2008, when he launched bermuda-attractions.com, one of the longest-standing independent guides to the island. A Certified Bermuda Specialist (Bermuda Tourism Authority), his work draws on personal visits, local contacts in Bermuda, and questions and trip reports from thousands of readers over the years.
Learn more about Raj Bhattacharya
Related Articles
Check out Top Cheap Restaurants to know about the inexpensive dining choices in Bermuda that serve great dishes and are quite popular in the island.
|
Visitors' Reviews and Comments
Gretchen (April 2016)
We dock at Kings Wharf... going to dinner at the Mad Hatter. Can we do this via ferry and walking?
Raj (bermuda-attractions.com) April 2016
Yes, it's about 350 yards walk from Hamilton ferry terminal along Bermudiana road. Check the last ferry timing on your return.
|