A Taste of True Bermuda: The Ultimate Guide to the Island's Favorite Local Eateries
Beyond the upscale dining and tourist-focused establishments in Bermuda lies a vibrant, authentic culinary scene beloved by locals. If you want to eat like a Bermudian, you need to step away from the hotel restaurants and discover the hidden gems, the no-frills food trucks, and the long-standing family institutions that form the heart of the island’s food culture.
This is not a list of fine dining establishments; this is a guide to where the community gathers for the best fish sandwich on raisin bread, the most potent Rum Swizzle, and heartwarming, homemade comfort food.
Prepare your taste buds for a journey through the authentic flavors of Bermuda, delivered with a smile and a healthy dose of island charm.
The Iconic Bermudian Fish Sandwich: A Must-Have Experience
You cannot talk about local Bermudian food without starting with the fish sandwich. It’s an island staple, often served on cinnamon raisin bread with tartar sauce—a sweet and savory combination that sounds unusual but is truly addictive.
Art Mel’s is, without a doubt, a Bermudian institution and perhaps the most famous spot for the island's signature dish. Tucked away on a back road, this is a no-frills, cash-only, takeout-only spot. What it lacks in decor, it makes up for with flavor and local legend. The vibe is casual and quick, the kind of place where locals line up out the door for their fix.
The signature item is the legendary fish sandwich: massive, stacked high with perfectly fried fish, tartar sauce, and optional coleslaw, all cradled between slices of warm raisin bread. The sheer size of this sandwich is impressive enough to feed two people.
Locals love it because it’s the original and the best - an authentic, messy, and deeply satisfying experience. Service is fast and friendly. A special tip: order ahead by phone if you can, as the queue can get long during peak lunch hours. Also, remember to bring cash!
9 St. Monica's Road, Pembroke (outskirts of Hamilton). Phone: 441/295-3965
Located in the picturesque town of St. George's, Munchies is another favorite that offers a slightly different experience, featuring a lovely little waterside patio where you can enjoy your meal with a view of the harbor. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, a great spot to soak up the historic surroundings.
Like Art Mel's, the star attraction here is the fish sandwich, with your choice of raisin, wheat, or white bread. Locals flock here for the quality of the fish and the laid-back setting. They also offer "Johnny Dogs" (hot dogs served in a sweet Johnny bread roll) and refreshing homemade juices.
The service is quick and the staff are always cheerful. A pro tip is to grab a seat outside and watch the boats bobbing in the water as you enjoy one of the island's best sandwiches.
50 Water Street, St. George’s, Bermuda. Phone (441) 261-5641.
Seaside Grill (Southampton)
This take-out spot offers a similar no-fuss experience, focusing on the quality of its fish sandwich rather than the setting. Widely regarded as serving one of the island's best fish sandwiches, it's known for its huge size, fresh local fish, and delicious raisin bread.
For the best, most authentic fish sandwich experience, many locals will argue that Seaside Grill is the undisputed king. It's a great option for grabbing a bite on your way to or from the South Shore beaches.
Phone: (441) 621-7000. Location: 121 Horseshoe Road, Southampton
Classic Pubs and Cocktail Culture
Bermuda has a strong British heritage, which means cozy, traditional pubs are an integral part of the local dining scene, often serving hearty comfort food alongside local brews and signature cocktails.
"Swizzle Inn, Swagger Out!" is the motto of this legendary establishment, founded in 1932. As Bermuda's oldest pub, it is the birthplace of the island's famous Rum Swizzle cocktail. The atmosphere is vibrant, lively, and covered in business cards and graffiti from visitors and locals alike who have passed through its doors over the decades. It's a true party spot.
Photo: djLicious, flickr, cc by 2.0
The signature beverage is, naturally, the Rum Swizzle - a potent blend of Gosling’s Black Seal rum, fruit juices, and secret ingredients that goes down perhaps a little too easily. Food-wise, they offer classic pub fare like hearty burgers, nachos, fish and chips, and fresh local seafood.
Locals love it for the fun atmosphere, the history, and the guarantee of a good time. The service is fast-paced and efficient, managing the constant buzz of patrons. Tip: pace yourself with the Swizzle!
3 Blue Hole Hill, Bailey's Bay, Hamilton Parish.
Housed in a historic cooperage, this traditional British-style pub offers a warm, friendly atmosphere and pairs its food with ales from Bermuda's oldest microbrewery. Classic pub fare, including fish and chips, calamari, and hearty sandwiches.
Photo: Frog & Onion Pub
The historic setting and craft beer selection make it a unique and popular destination for those seeking a traditional pub experience in the West End.
The Cooperage, Royal Naval Dockyard, Sandy's Parish.
You can reach by Bus #7 or 8, or by Ferry from City of Hamilton.
Casual Dining and Neighborhood Gems
For everyday meals, family gatherings, and reliable comfort food, these spots are where Bermudians go when they want a hearty, satisfying meal without any fuss.
A true Bermudian landmark on South Shore Road, Paraquet has been family-owned and operated for over half a century. It exudes a nostalgic, diner-style charm. The atmosphere is always bustling, a genuine crossroads for the community.
Paraquet is famous for its generous portions and home-style cooking. The all-day breakfast is a major draw, but the true local favorite is their traditional Codfish and Potato breakfast, served on weekends. This dish, a Bermudian staple, involves boiled salted cod served with boiled potatoes, onions, a white cream sauce, a banana and avocado slice.
Locals love the consistency, the value, and the feeling of tradition. Service is known to be incredibly friendly and quick. Tip: it's conveniently located near Elbow and Horseshoe beaches, making it a perfect post-swim food stop.
68 South Shore Road, Paget, Bermuda. Phone: (441) 236 9742
Located in the charming Flatts Village, this is a popular neighborhood spot with a bright, airy interior and a lovely outdoor patio perfect for sunny days. It has a modern, slightly trendy feel but retains a cozy, community vibe.
The menu focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients with a creative flair. They offer a diverse range of dishes, from healthy salads and vibrant bowls to hearty mains and decadent desserts. It’s a go-to for locals seeking quality ingredients and healthier options. Service is casual and welcoming.
8 North Shore Road, Flatts Village, Bermuda. Phone: 441-478-2300
A hip, urban cafe and restaurant in Hamilton, Devil's Isle is a favorite for the city crowd. With an industrial-chic interior and a bustling sidewalk patio, it has an energetic, metropolitan feel.
Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the menu is diverse and focuses on high-quality, often locally sourced ingredients. They are known for their excellent coffee program, inventive cocktails, and plenty of vegan and vegetarian options. Locals appreciate the cool atmosphere and reliable, quality food.
19 Burnaby Street, City of Hamilton, Bermuda. Phone: (441) 292-3284.
Food Trucks and Quick Bites
Sometimes you need great food fast, and Bermuda’s food trucks and quick-service spots are local legends in their own right, offering incredible flavors on the go.
Byrdies (DeGraff's)
A Hamilton landmark that has been serving up Bermudian breakfasts and fish cakes since 1939. Located near Victoria Park, this simple food truck is a local secret for those in the know. The portions are generous, the prices are great, and the food is authentic island comfort. It's the place for a quick, delicious morning bite.
12 Parsons Road , Hamilton, Bermuda
For a taste of the Caribbean, the Jamaican Grill is a beloved spot. The atmosphere is casual, and the focus is entirely on the flavor. Known for generous portions of authentic jerk BBQ, curries, oxtails, and fresh seafood, this is where locals go for spice and soul food. The value is excellent, and the food is consistently flavorful.
Another fantastic spot for cheap and cheerful Caribbean cuisine. D&C Grill West offers hearty and delicious Jamaican fare that is often sold by the pound, allowing you to build the perfect plate of jerk chicken, curries, and sides. It’s a no-frills, high-flavor experience that locals swear by.
Address: 2 Middle Road, Warwick Parish, Bermuda.
The restaurant is served by Bermuda bus routes #7 and #8.
Keith's Kitchen
A popular food truck in Hamilton, Keith's Kitchen is frequently praised by locals for having one of the best fish sandwiches on the island... high praise in Bermuda! It’s another excellent, quick option for an authentic, generously stacked meal on the move.
BAA Car Park, Hamilton, Bermuda. Phone: 441-295-1310
A diner-style restaurant that lives up to its name by offering a surprisingly diverse menu. From sushi to pizza to traditional Bermudian breakfasts, the Inn has it all. Locals flock here for the affordable prices and the sheer variety of good, reliable food.
Collectors Hill, 4 South Shore Road, Smith's Parish, Bermuda. Phone:(441)236-3133, Email:
[email protected]
More Local Haunts to Explore
The island's local food scene extends far beyond the most famous spots. Exploring these additional gems will give you an even deeper appreciation for Bermuda’s diverse culinary landscape.
For those in the know, LITT is a true hidden gem for fresh, local seafood. Located in Warwick, this casual spot is praised for its commitment to using local ingredients and its flavorful, home-style cooking. The ambiance is friendly and low-key, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal.
Signature dishes include their exceptional fresh fish and lobster (when in season). They also offer tasty fish tacos and a hearty fish chowder. The owner is often present, making the rounds to chat with diners, and their attentive staff ensures excellent service. The fresh, flavorful seafood and the genuine local charm are why LITT has won over so many Bermudian regulars.
87 South Road, Warwick Parish, Bermuda
For over four decades, the Lobster Pot has been a Hamilton institution, famous for its seafood and its cozy, maritime-themed ambiance. The decor, reminiscent of a ship's galley, offers a warm, friendly, and authentic Bermudian dining experience.
As the name suggests, fresh lobster is a star attraction, particularly during the September to March season. However, the true island classic to order here is the fish chowder, which many consider to be among the island's best.
Their deep, flavorful version is a must-try. The service is professional yet personal, and many locals celebrate special occasions here. It’s the kind of place where you can relax with a rum swizzle and enjoy some of the best seafood the island has to offer.
6 Bermudiana Road, City of Hamilton (Pembroke Parish). Phone: 441/292-6898.
Located in the Royal Naval Dockyard, this spot features a large, expansive patio with great views of the Great Sound. The atmosphere is casual and lively, and it often has a late-night menu. Specializes in seafood and Mediterranean-style dishes.
It also serves a huge fish sandwich on freshly baked raisin bread, delicious fried haddock, and tasty fish tacos. It's a consistently popular option in the West End with big portions and good drinks.
6 Dockyard Terrace, Royal Naval Dockyard, Sandy's Parish. Phone: (441) 234-5151
Sweet Treats and Coffee Breaks
Every good culinary tour needs a break for something sweet or a caffeine boost.
Located near the Swizzle Inn, Bailey’s is a long-standing local favorite for a cool treat on a hot day. They offer a huge variety of flavors, shakes, and floats. It’s a simple pleasure beloved by all ages.
2 Blue Hole Hill (in Bailey's Bay), Hamilton Parish.
Phone: 441/293-8605
If you need a proper coffee fix, Rock Island Coffee in Hamilton is the place. It has a loyal local following for its quality brews, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff. It's a great spot to relax, work, or catch up with friends.
48 Reid Street, Hamilton City, Bermuda. It is a block away from the water front.
Phone: 441/296-5241
Final Thoughts
Exploring Bermuda through its local eateries offers a genuine connection to the island’s culture and community. These are the places where memories are made, friends gather, and every meal feels like home. Skip the hotel chains and dive into the authentic, flavorful world of Bermudian local favorites - you won't regret it.
|
 By Raj Bhattacharya
Raj, a seasoned travel writer and Bermuda destination expert, has extensive global travel experience. This website reflects his profound insights, garnered over nearly two decades of dedicated findings and research on the island. Raj has assisted countless Bermuda-bound visitors by providing direct, personalized responses to their queries and imparting his wealth of knowledge through this platform. This site serves as an indispensable guide for those seeking informed and reliable insights into Bermuda's treasures.
|
Related Articles
|
Visitors' Reviews and Comments
|
