Bermuda Afternoon Tea

The old British tradition of having afternoon tea with cakes, pastries and cookies still prevails in Bermuda. If you visit the island and observe closely, you will see that almost all Bermudians are habitual drinkers of afternoon tea. Between 3 to 5pm, whether in work or leisure, a Bermudian would be craving for a cup of tea. 
There are several restaurants and cafes in Bermuda that serve afternoon tea to keep up with this long tradition. Some do it better than the others. Listed below are our favorites. Whenever we are in the island and looking for afternoon tea, we would choose one of the below mentioned restaurants or cafe. 
Heritage Court (Category: $$$) 
Heritage Court is a restaurant located inside the luxury hotel Hamilton Princess in Hamilton City. It has received recognition from the New York Times for the elegant and elaborate afternoon tea that it serves between 2:30p.m to 5p.m. You will get sandwiches, scones with Devonshire clotted cream and sweet pastries with a pot of English tea. 
From the British silver tea sets and Belgian fine china to Italian fine woven linens, sofas &áwing-backed chairs, the afternoon tea here spells of elegance and luxury. Remember that this is part of a luxury hotel, so prices would be high. But this in my view is the best afternoon tea in Bermuda today. 
Jasmine Lounge (Category: $$$) 
This restaurant is located at Fairmont Southampton Hotel. Traditional afternoon tea is served with freshly baked scones, jams and nice sandwiches. Open daily. Afternoon tea: 3pm to 5pm. Reservations not required. 
Sweet P (Category: $$) 
A tea room has come up in St. George (in Feb 2012) at the grounds of Stewart Hall with a nice garden setting. This is where the popular Bermuda Perfumery is also located. Other than traditional tea, they serve lots of innovative and yummy snack items like miniature brioches, chicken coronation sandwiches, rum babas, brioche pastry soaked in rum syrup, miniature cakes, scones, other pastries, finger sandwiches etc. All these are prepared using fresh local ingredients. 
So if you plan for a Walking Tour of St. George in the morning, then in the afternoon you can walk down to Sweet P and have a high tea for your lunch in a lush outdoor garden setting (they can also arrange for indoor seating). You get an opportunity to scan the perfumery as well. 
Sweet P is located on Queen Street at Stewart Hall premises. Tea Hours: 1:00pm-4:00pm on Wednesdays and Saturdays; Reservation recommended. 
Phone: (441)705-2390; Email [email protected] 
Cafe 4 (Category: $) 
Located in Hamilton with indoor as well as outdoor dining option with great garden setting, they serve traditional afternoon tea along with nice pastries. Location: Windsor Place, 18 Queen Street, Hamilton. Open Monday to Saturday. 
The Dockyard Pastry Shop &áBistro (Category: $$) 
This eatery is located at Royal Naval Dockyard with a small garden setting and you can have your tea al fresco under the garden umbrellas. The English style afternoon tea is served between 2pm to 5pm accompanied with scones, jam &ájelly, sandwiches, and optionally with a glass of sparkling wine. Open daily from 9am to 5pm. 12 Dockyard Terrace (located at the entrance of Victualling Yard). 
Other places serving afternoon tea: 
1) AS Coopers on Front Street (Hamilton City) offers tea at their balcony restaurant upstairs. 
2) Rock Island (48 Reid St. Hamilton): Although this is a coffee shop, it serves nice tea as well. 
Gluten-Free Afternoon Tea: 
Jasmine Lounge at Fairmont Southampton and Heritage Court at Hamilton Princess can serve gluten free afternoon tea. 
Places that once served great afternoon tea 
Homer's Cafe (Category: $) X No longer offered 
This cafe is located at the Botanical Gardens inside Masterworks Museum of Art in Paget and provides an excellent relaxed ambience amongst the nature. During the summer months, you can have your afternoon tea in the open terrace area under the Lily Pergola. 
A pathway leads to a lovely rose garden. The traditional afternoon tea is served on china tea pot &ácups between 2pm to 4pm (reservation required). The afternoon tea here also entitles you to reduced entry fee for the adjacent Masterworks Art Museum &áGallery. 
Located at Elbow Beach Hotel in Paget Parish, you can get a great view of the south shore from the Veranda Lounge. They serve afternoon tea from 3pm to 5pm in a typical English style. It comes on a tiered tray complete with exquisite tea sandwiches and tea cakes. Update February 2014: They no longer serve afternoon tea. 
Located in Waterloo House Hotel, this restaurant has a wonderful view of the Hamilton Harbor. They serve afternoon tea here. So you get a great view as you have your tea. 
Lighthouse Tea Room X Closed  
Located below the Gibbs Hill Lighthouse in Southampton Parish, this tea room has been our all time favorite for afternoon tea. They serve full English afternoon tea complete with Devonshire cream and homemade scones. The owner Heidi Cowen does all the baking. 
If you are at the dockyard in the afternoon, you can have tea at this small &ácasual restaurant located at the western end of Clocktower Mall. 
Related Articles 
Visitors' Reviews &áComments 
Share your experience.